Monday, 22 June 2009

Genre Comparative Study





These two artists both perform their songs within the genre of Comedy Rock. Whilst there are many similarities between the two songs that tie into the genre, there are also many differences between the two. The first of the two songs is by a band called Bloodhound Gang, and is a song called 'The Bad Touch', which is sometimes known as 'Discovery Channel' for it's famous chorus. The band, whilst fitting the comedy rock genre, seem to have taken a more hip-hop approach to this particularly song, with the use of dance music and rapping. The second of the two songs is 'Tribute' by Tenacious D. This band is stereotypical to the comedy rock genre; however, fit the role of two characters who aspire to be hard rock stars.

Whilst in the same genre, the two songs take a very different approach to meeting the conventions and creating their comedy. The first of the two, 'The Bad Touch', relies on blatant and obvious sexual innuendos which are made humorous by their pure filth that is spoken so freely. On the other hand 'Tribute' is more personal to the actual characters within the story space of the song, who are two brothers wanting to be rock stars. The completely ridiculous lyrics that sound as if they have been made up on the spot help emphasize the failure of these aspiring rock stars, yet is comical as they insist they are rock stars, and that they wrote 'the greatest song in the World'. Both of the songs focus strongly on their artists whilst following some form of progressive narrative, with the Bloodhound Gang rounding up the public into a cage progressively, and Tenacious D recording their song to a story. This follows closely the generic conventions of a music video, but even more so that of the comedy rock genre, where the lyrics often trace a progressive story shown in the video.

The two songs also tie very closely to the convention of reflecting what is happening visually with the characteristics of the music. At the very beginning of 'The Bad Touch' the pelvic thrusting of the monkeys (and Bloodhound Gang dressed as monkeys) is in time with the opening beat. Similarly in 'Tribute', the two artists begin to play their song in the recording booth as it starts, reflecting with the visuals of the video what is happening in the music. As the music drops in towards the beginning of 'The Bad Touch' the other characters (specifically the women) are brought into the video, which sets the tone for the rest of the song, with the women being portrayed as sexually desirable. This reflects the music as it this point the beat lifts and becomes slightly faster and more exciting. As the music picks up throughout the song between the choruses the visuals represent the panic of the captured citizens and the partying mammals, along side the increasingly shorter cuts between shots.

Thursday, 18 June 2009

Research - Initial Six Stage Analysis

Calvin Harris' song, 'The Girls', follows a number of typical conventions of a music video. One of the foremost and more obvious conventions would be the abstract scene in which the video takes place. Seemingly in a location, that lacks location, the video is set in what appears to be a completely white space. This is commonly used in music videos (in a variety of colours) to either draw the artists out of the plot or narrative of the music video, or to draw focus to them as individuals. Another convention that is found in 'The Girls' is the dancers that manoeuvre around the artist. Although they dominant a lot of the camera shots, their lack of individuality and the fact that they dance around Calvin Harris, makes the artist remain the main focus. This is commonly used in music videos to fill space with movement, as to give vibe to the music. This convention works particularly well with how the lyrics fit with the visuals that are presented. As the song reads 'I get all the girls', the girls in the music video dance around Calvin, surrounding him on all sides. However, saying this, all of the girls in the song seem to take no notice of Calvin, as he wonders through them. This again reinforces this idea of an abstract scene where Calvin is detached from reality, fortunately in the company of ladies.

Just as the visuals reflect what is being said in the lyrics, the visuals also work in symphony with the characteristics of the music. At the beginning of the songs the song is dominated by the voice in the background, and the music is relatively low key, with a slow tempo. During this period the girls are very blank and dance in a jolting and robotic manner, moving at the climax of every sentence, matching the low set tempo. As soon as the tempo picks up and the louder music kicks in, a new group of girls dive into the camera shot and begin to dance in time with the newly set tempo. As the song progresses and the music continues, progressively, newly coloured girls begin entering the dance sequence. At the very end of the song, when the music comes to a sudden stop, all of the girls disappear and their clothes are left on the ground. This could represent either that Calvin Harris now has no girls, or could represent the sexual nature of his relationships, and how he bashes and dashes!

Throughout the song there is a very strong focus on Calvin Harris, most likely an attempt to promote him. As well as this, there is a visual effect at the beginning of the song with the director's surname, 'Gehrig'. Although this does not state his position or relation to the music video, it raises a level of ambiguity which may catalyst curiosity to look into who he is. Or he could quite simply just be tagging his work.

There are a number of visuals as well that are included in order to capture the audiences interest, because they like what they're seeing. The large number of dancing ladies in the music video are just one of the key features that keeps the audience engaged, and quite possibly suggests that the song is targeted at a male audience (with the hip thrusting being a key feature!). However, there is just as much appeal to ladies as Calvin Harris looks particularly rugged and sexy in this video. There is a particularly sexually dance move in the song, where all the girls are lined up with their legs in the air, and then split their legs and at the end of the row of the girls is Calvin Harris. This suggests further the sexual nature to Calvin Harris' relationships. What a God.

However, in challenge to the lyrics, all the girls in the video happen to be white and slim, despite Calvin Harris clearly stating that he 'likes those big girls'. Poor Calvin clearly isn't getting what he wants.


The intertextuality is not entirely clear in this music video, but there are some references to the 80s, with the 'bob' hair style which all of the girls in the video have, as well as the turtle neck jumpers. Also Calvin Harris' scruffy laid back look reinforces this idea. This refers to the pop culture of the 1980s, and furthermore to his previous song 'Acceptable In The 80s', making this a consistent theme throughout his music.